The Scary Mommy Community is a place to find support and camaraderie with amazing moms who love to help one another. We are scattered all around the world, of all different colors and sizes and lifestyles, united by a single thing: motherhood.

Please create a profile to post and for access to all of boards. It's quick and completely painless!

Motherhood Comes Naturally (and other vicious lies) is available in stores, and online, NOW. Do you have it yet? Have you told all your friends and family about it? **Get it, share it, and spread the joy!**
How Much?
  • GritsGrits
    Posts: 3,749Member
    How much of a say do you let your children (say between 4 and 10) have
    in decisions about their day to day lives. I don't mean life-altering as
    in whether or not to see a doctor, go to school, etc. Those are
    obviously parents' decisions. I mean like haircuts, clothing, friends,
    what to eat, etc.



    DD8 and her dad and I are dealing with a real power struggle here. She,
    of course, is of the mind that she can do as she pleases. I still feel
    like I should be making decisions about friends she's allowed to play
    with, the clothing she wears, what she eats for snacks, because,
    obviously I know best. But DH raises an interesting point when he says
    that some of these things are things I won't always be able to control,
    and she needs to start gaining some experience when it comes to things
    like friends that are bad influences and haircuts that she hates. I'm
    trying to save her some heartache, and I know on some level he's right,
    but is she old enough?? I don't feel like she thinks things through very
    well, even though she's very intelligent...she seems to be slightly
    lacking in the common sense department. I've always felt like my parents
    let go of the reigns a little too soon. Maybe that's why I feel the way
    I do. What do you ladies think?? Around what age (generally) should
    parents start to relinquish a little control, and in what areas?
    "I believe in being strong when everything seems to be going wrong. I believe that happy girls are the prettiest girls. I believe that tomorrow is another day, and I believe in miracles." ~Audrey Hepburn
  • LA_PygmyHerderLA_PygmyHerder
    Posts: 1,239Member

    The best thing I can say is to pick your battles wisely. Clothing, give her a choice between several outfits and that gives her some control and she'll feel as though it really was her decision. And as for friends, maybe a talk about people who make good choices and bad choices is in order. I've had that talk many many times.


    But remember, I let my 7 year old boy get his ear peirced after he begged for 2 years and let the boys have mohawks in the summer. I let my dd have choices too. Like she has her own style which is awesome. But I put things together with peices she likes.

  • TVmommyTVmommy
    Posts: 453Member
    My DD is 9 It depends on what kind of day she is having. She has ADHD so some days are just a mess. I give her choices about food (breakfast) and clothes pretty much on a daily basis. She is allowed to pick out clothes she likes when we are shopping, with the understanding that if I say no that's it. All choices are subject to approval. I will also make the effort to explain to her why I don't like the choices I don't agree with. Also, with friends I maintain the ultimate veto as well, again with a reasonable explanation as to why I don't think the person in question would make a good friend.

    We had the haircut disaster last summer. Over the winter she had been after me to get her hair cut. It was down to the middle of her back and very thick. She wanted her hair short like mine. I decided to wait and see if she kept talking about it in the spring and sure enough she did. right before the end of the school year I took her to get her hair cut. We sat down with the stylist together and talked about how she wanted her hair. She opted for a pixie cut and I thought she looked adorable. She was okay with it for the first day. The next day she woke up and decided she hated it when she saw herself in the mirror. I talked her through it but it took about a week. She has asked about getting her hair cut again this spring. I am reminding her of what happened last year. But, ultimately it's going to happen if she keeps asking and I have the money.....

    So, that's the way I handle it. I hope it helps. I know how hard it is. I am an over protective mother.... Good luck!
    Darling, a true lady takes off her dignity with her clothes and does her whorish best! At other times you can be as modest and dignified as your persona requires.
  • boring_nameboring_name
    Posts: 667Member
    Every family is different.. this is what worked/works in mine.

    As far as clothes I think I stopped choosing their outfits by 6 easily... but retained veto power (mismatched boy or too low cut etc...) My kids learned my mantra early.... "No Butts, No Boobs, No Belly" keeps everything covered! LOL

    Hair we discuss.. I let them have say from the time they can say what they want.. but again.. veto power. If it is say blue hair... our elementary schools don't allow it.. so it's a no. Last year at 13 my DD decided she was ready to cut all her hair off! EEK.. we discussed it for about 2 weeks.. then off it went.. (about 20 inches to over the ears/super short pixie).. and colored purple (her high school does allow color). 

    By 8 my kids were making their own lunches and snacks (most of the time). You have taught her what a healthy choice is and an unhealthy choice.. you can supervise and advise still (also.. veto power.. no one really needs 3 cupcakes as a snack... but some veggies or cheese and crackers with 1 cookie is alright)

    Yup.. choose your battles wisely... you don't want constant power struggles all through the teen years.. you'll have enough emotional up/down/all around to deal with. Good Luck!
    B
  • Siren
    Posts: 2Member
    My daughter is 5, so that's still a little young to make all of her own decisions, but I try to ease her into the whole process. She, too, has been bugging me to get her hair cut. It's down to the elastic in her pants, beautiful and curly at the end...hence why I don't want to let it go. I tried what TVmommy did and let it go to see how long she would keep pestering me about it. She's eased up, but still occasionally reminds me or her aunts that I won't let her cut it. If she still wants it cut off by the time she starts 1st grade in the fall, I'll probably let her.

    As for clothes, she's still at the point where I can pick out her wardrobe and she likes it. But if we go shopping for specific things like shoes, a bathing suit, a special occasion dress or her Halloween costume, ect...it's completely up to her. I let her pick out her own clothes for school so long as they match and are weather appropriate. I give her the options of what she can have for breakfast and she chooses as well as how she wants her hair done for school.

    We didn't have very much money growing up so I mostly wore hand me downs and thrift store clothes, but I never cared. I don't want to raise a child hell bent on owning things because of their material value or popularity, which is why she doesn't have more control yet. I believe it also depends on the child themselves and how you feel as a mother about what they're ready for. Some don't express the maturity to make these decisions until much later than others, and some do quite earlier. My daughter will be one of the early risers...but my son is a completely different story.

  • Katescrazymom
    Posts: 1,848Member
    I let my 3 yo dd pick her own outfits. Most of her clothes coordinate fairly well, and I like seeing what she'll pick. I even let her pick short sleeves in the winter, but draw the line at shorts. My mom's line was alway "take the jacket/coat/hat/". That way we had what we needed, but got to make a choice. I've also let her choose if she wants bangs or not. She hasn't asked about earrings yet.
  • etherieletheriel
    Posts: 713Member

    2 of my kids (DS10 and DD12) have ADHD and the other (DD14) is very headstrong and independent. I have to pick my battles or we'd all just be fighting over stupid stuff all the time.

    As far as clothes go, I've let my kids choose their own since they were of school age, but I reserve the right to veto anything that shows too much skin or isn't weather appropriate. Same thing with their haircuts. Hair grows back and if they're made fun of for their clothing choices, then they'll quickly learn not to wear that again.

    All 3 of my kids make their own breakfast, lunch, and snacks. They each get to plan 2 dinners per week fro the family. I feel that between nutrition lessons during school and me setting a good example, they are perfectly capable of making good food choices. It also helps that I don't keep junk food in the house, pretty much making that a non-choice.

    Choice of friends is an important issue. I have let my kiddos choose their friends. Any of their friends can hang out at our house and that's never been a problem. If they want to go to a friends house, then I have to meet their parents first. I did have to have the "making good choices in friends" talk with my son this year because he kept getting into trouble with the same 2 boys (who both also have ADHD) at school. He and his friends have learned to channel their energy though into more positive activities, like reading contests.

    Your DD is 8 and IMO it's time to start letting her make some decisions. I know it's hard to let go, but you're going to have to eventually. The more practice she gets in making her own decisions, the more confident you and she both will be in her ability to make good decisions in the long run. Start by letting her make the less important decisions, i.e. what to wear to school. Gradually work up to bigger decisions. By all means, make suggestions and offer good choices, like just having healthy snack items in the house. She does still need your guidance after all. Ultimately though, our goal as good parents is to raise productive members of society that are well-equipped to make good decisions, not just for themselves, but for the greater good. If she never has the opportunity to make her own decisions now, she won't feel confident in her choices later on in life.

    If I'm not supposed to do it, how come I can?
  • GritsGrits
    Posts: 3,749Member
    Well put, ladies. Our main battle right now is that she NEVER wants to listen. So I'm having a hard time getting her to accept "no". She also is bad about impulse control, so when things aren't looking like she's going to get her way, she flips her lid. My point is, if she can't be mature and accept that some things are just above her comprehension and TRUST me instead of acting like a little know-it-all, then I can't feel like she's heard what I've told her and used what I've taught her. For example, we have had an issue with her wanting to start the car when she gets in. The key is stuck in the ignition, and too expensive to have it taken out, so when she gets in, she turns the key over and her dad or I aren't in it. We've explained to her that it's dangerous, but she scoffs at us, and the next time, no matter what the consequence, she does it again. Tonight she lost her summer kickoff party because of it. It's not the first time she's gotten in trouble for it. It's just so frustrating, and doesn't give me a lot of hope for her teen years...if she survives them.
    "I believe in being strong when everything seems to be going wrong. I believe that happy girls are the prettiest girls. I believe that tomorrow is another day, and I believe in miracles." ~Audrey Hepburn