The Scary Mommy Community is a place to find support and camaraderie with amazing moms who love to help one another. We are scattered all around the world, of all different colors and sizes and lifestyles, united by a single thing: motherhood.

Please create a profile to post and for access to all of boards. It's quick and completely painless!

Motherhood Comes Naturally (and other vicious lies) is available in stores, and online, NOW. Do you have it yet? Have you told all your friends and family about it? **Get it, share it, and spread the joy!**
Not talking to sister - am I doing the right thing?
  • JenInHeels
    Posts: 101Member
    This post is about my sister.  She is 3 years my junior and we could not be anymore different.  


     


    Anyhow, I have always been the good big sister.  As my sister has gotten older and married and had her first child she has turned into a prim-donna urban mom.  She fancies her new house, state of the art appliances, three brand new cars and pities anyone who rents or drives something that doesn’t require a loan.  So since she has been turning this prima-donna self righteous leaf she has been harder and harder to get along with.  It seems everything revolves around her and her 3 year old and if anyone tries to pluck her rose colored glass off she breaks down and loses it.  She gets really upset or starts to cry.  Here are some events that have occurred over the past 4 years or so:


     


    MY DIVORCE: Okay, so this actually happened 7 years ago but she did nothing to help me out.  I went to her house once in tears after I found out my ex was cheating.  She didn’t invite me in and we sat on her porch while I cried.  The whole time I felt like I was putting her out and taking up her time.  She ushered me away as soon as possible. 


     


    I GOT RAN OVER BY A TRUCK: My friend and I were crossing the street one night when a 19 year old ran over the both of us.  I broke my nose in 7 different places, tore muscle in my knee and was so swelled up I couldn’t see right for over a week.  I had to take 3 weeks off of work and go to physical therapy for months.  My (then boyfriend) had to help as much as possible while still working and my kids were 6 and 9 at the time.  She didn’t come to visit me once and she didn’t call me once.


     


    MOTHERS DAY: For the past 3 years (yes, since her son was born) – I have called her asking if we can get together with our mom for lunch and maybe a mani or pedi.  Each year she throws a fit and asks why cant mothers day just be about her since she is a mom now.  She gets mad and even said to me one year “I don’t see why we have to visit mom.”


     


    CHRISTMAS: Christmas has been held at her house for the past 5 years.  The first year her son was born we had it at her house since her kid was only about 6 months old.  Then the year after that (and the year after that) I brought up perhaps hosting at my place.  She got very upset saying that her son needs his own bed for naps and she doesn’t want to have to drive back home with all the gifts in the car.  (But apparently it’s OK for me to drive back home with all the gifts for TWO kids in my car).  My other thought for Christmas at my house was that I am centerally located and it’s at least a 45 minute cut off my grandfathers commute time which she didn’t seem to care about. I finally won last year since her child was three but it was like pulling teeth.  My dad had to actually talk to her and basically tell her to get over it and the whole family would like a different venue.


     


    BIRTHDAYS AND ANNIVERSARIES: My husband and I scheduled our anniversary trip for our first year about 4 months before any mention of a birthday party for her son.  We had everything paid for and booked.  About two weeks before we left she decided to throw the birthday party that exact same weekend and got upset with us when we wouldn’t cancel our trip to go to party.


     


    THE FINAL STRAW – CRUSHING MY DAUGHTER: My daughter is 9.  She auditioned for a part in a community theatre play and landed it on her first try!  She rehearsed for MONTHS with each rehearsal being 4 – 6 hours.  The play was a real play and the cast included kids 6 up to adults as old at 68.  The tickets sold for almost $20.00 a piece and were in a real theatre.  My DD wanted her aunt to go so badly!  There were 8 different show times that she could have gone to.  She refused.  I kept asking her nicely to go see her niece.  My mom asked her nicely to go see her niece.  She wouldn’t.  My DD had 30 other people go – friends, family (even divorced aunts and uncles came) – my x and his whole family came, her baby sitter and cheer coach and dance teacher went but her aunt never showed up.  She was crushed.


     


    After that happened I decided it wasn’t healthy to associate with her anymore.  I am sick of being the “big sister who is better then that and get’s over everything”.  I’ve been doing it to long.  I deleted her from face book and have cut her off.  I haven’t talked to her since Christmas and I really don’t want to.


     


    She recently suffered a miscarriage.  She told my mother she was upset because I never called her to check on her.  I do feel bad about that but then I re-run through everything that she has done and the way that she has behaved and I don’t want to go back into that toxic relationship.  In all honesty if my baby sister would call me and say “sorry” for being so selfish towards everyone and tell me she needs me I’d be there in a second.  But I can’t bring myself to just “get over it” – yet again to make family peace.


     


    What do you all think?  Sorry this was so stinking long.

  • CanadianMamaCanadianMama
    Posts: 9,606Administrator, Moderator
    I think you are doing the right thing. She's selfish, seems to be aware that she's selfish and just doesn't care. You and your whole family deserve to be treated much better!

    community-manager


  • unforgivenunforgiven
    Posts: 12,700Confessional Manager
    My sister and I also don't have the best relationship. We have had some ugly fights. Family is still family. As much as it hurts sometimes, maybe she just thought this warranted a break of silence to check in? Even if it is a toxic relationship, you checking in on her doesn't have to mean you guys try to force something that isn't there. The choice is yours. You don't have to 'get over' anything if you don't want to obviously.. some things just take time. 

    confessional-manager

    "What looks like torture is a time to rejoice
    What sounds like thunder is a comforting voice
    When what is beautiful looks broken and crushed
    And I say I don't know you
    But you say it's finished"
  • [Deleted User]
    Posts: 7,022
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
    well behaved women seldom make history
  • [Deleted User]
    Posts: 7,022
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
    well behaved women seldom make history
  • momnipotentmomnipotent
    Posts: 498Member
    fuck that. i mot certainly would not contact her after all the.bullshit you put up with. the fucking.nerve of her to assume you would want anything to do with her after acting like such a royal cunt. im all for being the bigger person but it sounds like youve tried that, anything from here on out would be less of being abig person and more being like a doormat.
    big hugs to you you do not deserve the pure mind fuckery she is pulling.
    *ad astra per alia porci*
    my nuts hang like there aint no curfew
  • MarySunshineMarySunshine
    Posts: 5,450Member
    My sister doesn't have a hubs or family yet...but she's kinda self centered. She's blown me and her nephews off twice since October.

    Ugh. I have to stop thinking about mine. We're going on vacation with her next week. I want to have a nice time...


    Yeah the "good big sister" stuff is a pain in the ass and complete bullshit. I know I'm done being the good big sister, too.

    If it means a lot to your mom to email her, send a brief one and be done with her.
    I'm as sexy as a burp mid-kiss. Watch out!

  • MarySunshineMarySunshine
    Posts: 5,450Member
    Your sister sounds like my BIL. We are no longer on speaking terms with him and it's been fantastic...
    I'm as sexy as a burp mid-kiss. Watch out!

  • Charlotte_SometimesCharlotte_Sometimes
    Posts: 1,756Member
    Something it has taken my 40 years to learn... blood is NOT everything.   Many times we have people who are family due to circumstance but these people are still people we wouldn't befriend in a million years if there was no blood tie. 

    There is only so much negativity and abuse one person can take.  I have had periods with my own mother where we did not have any contact and I can honestly say that those were some of the happiest periods in my life.  The only reason I am in touch with her now is because she is all alone (her own doing!) and I let the guilt suck me in to having contact with her.  :(

    She is constantly pushing my niece on me though, trying to get me to give a damn what my niece says or posts on FB or whatever and I am of the opinion that my niece (24) is a self centered, self righteous little twat and I have no interest in what is going on in her life.  Sure, I want her to be happy but aside from that, I don't care... and my mother is big on this "blood" thing when I have decided that 'blood' is really irrelevant to some degree!
    "But a lesson must be lived
    In order to be learned"

    Ani DiFranco, Manhole
  • MistressHeidiMistressHeidi
    Posts: 973Member
    @ Charlotte_Sometimes is right... Blood is not everything. I have a wonderful sister and a horrible brother. I have friends who treat me better then family does. You deserve to be treated better, so does the rest of your family. Stepping away from a toxic relationship like that is what's best for you and your kids. You are so doing the right thing.


  • momofdbbmomofdbb
    Posts: 9,077Member
    I would probaly just send a sympathy card. But I send cards fir just about antmything.
    " Wibbly wobbly timey wimey ......." The Doctor
    " I'm a leafe on the wind..watch how I soar ." Wash :((
    " Oh the wall had it comming.' Sherlock Holmes
    yea I am geek !!
  • AnonUser33
    Posts: 743Guest
    My own personal experience with this sort of situation is this. The second I break down and call my mother because something horrible has happened, I get sucked back into her bull almost immediately. No matter how strong I try to be and how many times I tell myself I will not get sucked in I do. It is because everything is about her. No matter how bad things are with me or my family, things with her are always worse. She is demanding and controlling. My life and my childrens life is so much better without her or her drama.
  • Charlotte_SometimesCharlotte_Sometimes
    Posts: 1,756Member
    unknown1 said:

    My own personal experience with this sort of situation is this. The second I break down and call my mother because something horrible has happened, I get sucked back into her bull almost immediately. No matter how strong I try to be and how many times I tell myself I will not get sucked in I do. It is because everything is about her. No matter how bad things are with me or my family, things with her are always worse. She is demanding and controlling. My life and my childrens life is so much better without her or her drama.



    yup.  Me too.
    "But a lesson must be lived
    In order to be learned"

    Ani DiFranco, Manhole
  • mami_of_3mami_of_3
    Posts: 163Member
    She sounds like my sister, except mine isn't married or has children yet. I tried cutting her off and currently I am basically, if she texts I answer briefly(how are you's is the whole convo, after that I stop the texts) and I won't answer her calls. I am done with the lying and manipulation. Everyone in the family thinks I should "stop being mean" and call her but I am done. My family and I come 1st, not her, not anymore. And I feel better than ever. She would always put me against my mother and grandma and I will not tolerate it any longer. I think you are doing the right thing. That way you don't get sucked back in like I did before. But maybe you can have a distant relationship? Like they said before, send her a card or email but keep your distance. That's just my opinion.
    If you change their diaper, they will immediately poop in the new one.
    If you mop the floor, they will spill something.
    If you put on fresh socks, you will immediately step on whatever was spilled.
    If you're tired, they will not be.
    If you love them, you will see the beauty in it all.
  • irishlassirishlass
    Posts: 6,726Member
    I am a firm believer in the importance of family. You sound like you do need a break from her, for sure, and she sounds like a handful! But maybe have a chat with her about how you feel like you are taken for granted sometimes?

    I have to say though, I think family doesn't have to be blood. My best friend is my family. We can go through times of not talking for 2months just cause we are busy, but we still love each other.

    Your sister is not your responsibility but I personally would make an effort to maintain contact and maintain a relationship. It sounds like she means a lot to your dd and maybe you can help her see that. Be open and honest with her.
    "Be who you are and say what you feel. Because those who matter don't mind and those who mind don't matter." - Dr. Seuss
  • LifeofchaosLifeofchaos
    Posts: 984Member
    Did you let your sister know why you are distancing yourself? I dont blame you at all and completely understand. Just this week i had to remove my sister from my life. It sucks but she is an emotional vampire and truthfully having a relationship with her just isnt worth it.
    Perhaps your sister cant even see how selfish she is being..... If you havent tried talking to her Id shoot her an email explaining your stance.
  • Jjva
    Posts: 47Member
    I don't particularly subscribe to the belief that you have to associate people because they are blood relatives. I have a brother I don't speak to at all, yet I am relatively close to my step siblings. There are things you can forgive and things you can't. And for your own mental health, sometimes you need to take a break from your siblings. I don't think she's done anything "I'm never speaking to you again" bad, but a break for a while? Yeah, that seems right.
  • goldie
    Posts: 108Member
    I have a sister 3 years younger than me who has done so many shitty things to me over the years I just stopped trying with her.  I came to realize that strangers treat me better than my own sister, and she is simply someone I choose not to be around.  If we have to go to a family get together, I am nice, but distant.  I never initiate contact with her anymore.  I have let my resentments against her go, but I no longer put myself in a position where she can hurt me...she's more of an acquaintance than a sister now.  I even had her come over months ago and explained to her how badly she had been hurting me, and she still never said sorry.  Fuck her
  • shadylaneshadylane
    Posts: 3,037Member
    i would have called and given her my condolences to show her that i do care even though she's an asshole, after all she is ur sister and will be forever whether u like it or not so u might as well try to be on good terms. i don't believe u have to associate with someone just b/c ur related either, but if its someone ur going to have to see u might as well try to get along.  that doesn't mean u have to be up her ass,  u can still keep her at a distance so as not to be affected by her selfishness, just a phone call or email every now and then. just to let her know that it isn't b/c u don't care, and that ur available should she decide to stop behaving like an asshole. does she know why u have cut contact? if u haven't explaned it to her, maybe send her an email giving ur condolences and explaining that while u would like to be there for her, u can't expose u and ur daughter to any more disappointment by her, that her behavior has really hurt ur family, u hope she understands and if she's interested in repairing the relationship u would be willing to discuss things with her. and that u do love her but its just not healthy for u to be involved in her life at this point in time. maybe u not being there for her during her time of need has made her realize the error of her ways and u two can work things out. i agree with jjva that she hasn't done something so awful as to never speak to her again, just keep her at a distance for a while. she will eventually realize that being selfish gets her nowhere in the end.
    ~slim shady~
  • luckymama
    Posts: 94Member
    I would send a sympathy card so I didn't have to speak to her and then I'd go about my life and spend time with people who aren't so selfish. Adopt a new sister-friend to fill that role. No need to cater to her! Good luck. And hugs - no matter how old we are, it still hurts when family isn't there for us.