Portman shames The Golden Globes for ignoring female directors
Natalie Portman became a true hero of the she-people last night at The Golden Globes when she called out the lack of female directors in the Best Director category with a jab so smooth, and so sharp that dudes were saying, “Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha oh shit I’m bleeding.”
Portman, who has spoken out in support of the #MeToo movement with her own stories of sexual harassment, came out on stage to present the award for Best Director with filmmaker Ron Howard. She didn’t mince words when it came to pointing out the obvious — that every nominee was a man.
— People (@people) January 8, 2018
Did she just–? Oh yes, she did. After Howard said, “We’re honored to be here to present the award for best director,” Portman stepped to the mic and said, “And here are the all-male nominees.”
Portman’s comment was in reference to the fact that all five nominees for Best Director were men despite some phenomenal work by female directors: there was Patty Jenkins, whose film Wonder Woman became the highest-grossing superhero origin movie of all time; Dee Rees, who directed the critically-acclaimed film Mudbound; Kathryn Bigelow, who directed the incredible movie Detroit; and Greta Gerwig, who was not nominated for directing even though her film, Lady Bird, was nominated for Best Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy, Best Actress, Best Supporting Actress, and Best Screenplay.
Many celebrated what Portman did:
Their faces after Natalie Portman dropped shade on them pic.twitter.com/GR60FnKeYR
— Isaac (@WorldofIsaac) January 8, 2018
Natalie Portman's "here are the all male nominees" moment is basically what anyone introducing an all male anything should do. e.g. "Here is the all male panel." "Here is the all male bibliography."
— Dr. Shyama R (@MedievalPhDemon) January 8, 2018
But then, of course, there were some men who just had to get on Twitter and “dude it all up.” Unfortunately for them, their tweet complaints about Portman’s words only showed how justified she was in saying them:
That time of the month for #NataliePortman? How rude could she be? Totally disrespected all the Best Director nominees trying to win a few virtue signaling points by whining about the nominees being all men. Shame.
— Mark Dice (@MarkDice) January 8, 2018
You lost everyone at “that time of the month.”
Dear Natalie: you have worked with talented men, and men who gave you opportunities. Just because the 5 nominees are men, doesn't mean it's because of their anatomy. Steven Spielberg…is pretty good I hear. #NataliePortman
— Mark Rubello (@MarkRubello) January 8, 2018
You’re right, Steven Spielberg was not nominated for his penis (although I’m sure it’s spectacular and does a phenomenal job of combining technical mastery with commercial success). But when you look at the fact that, as Barbra Streisand pointed out, only one woman (Streisand) has ever won the Golden Globe for Best Director, and that was in 1984, you might start to think, “Wow. That’s an awful lot of talented penises.”
Oh, and p.s., Natalie: You earned those opportunities through talent and hard work.
And to add to the ridiculousness, some even mansplained why Portman was wrong in the comments of the below tweet, which explained why their criticism was wrong.
That awkward moment when you accidentally prove her point. pic.twitter.com/0lkeogT5c3
— Molly (@isteintraum) January 8, 2018
Yeah but the 5 guys didn’t deserve to have their moment in the spotlight dimmed like that.— Ticket to the Unraveling (@DrunkEnough) January 8, 2018
He doesn’t say women only directed 7% of films, he says only 7% of the highest grossing films where directed by women. Ie people by coincidence watched more films directed by men which is why they are shortlisted.— Jamie Rowland (@rowloefc) January 8, 2018
Agree with this point, and yes more women should be given the opportunity to direct big movies and all. But if your movies shit your not gonna get an award? I honestly think that should be the height of it. Don’t give them an award cause they’re a female director lol— Ben (@M3TALDetector) January 8, 2018
It doesn't need to be attention brought to the fact that they were all male most directors in Hollywood are male just by statistics it was most likely They're all going to Be Male she's an actor not a politician no one wants her opinion— sargentiø (@5tudmuffen) January 8, 2018
The old “no one from that group got those accolades because no one from that group deserved them” argument is tired and has been used to rationalize prejudice over and over again. When it’s one award one time, then you might be talking about the quality of the available candidates. But when it’s 99% of the awards, you need to start doing some critical thinking and consider the role of history in these decisions.
Natalie Portman, with the addition of just two words, didn’t just point out the bias, she spoke its name. And, what’s more, she did it to its face. What she did was brave, overdue, and appreciated. Therefore, we are going to give her the last word:
— NataliePortman.com (@natpdotcom) January 8, 2018
You can donate to Time’s Up Now here.