Scary Mommy 2026 Readers' Choice Awards Best Domestic Wine Brands
We’ll drink to that!

Look, we know that some of you aren’t drinking much of late, and that is totally fine, but some of us are. And, on top of that, some of us like to drink local, and by local I mean within America. So if you’re looking for a domestic wine brand you can find pretty easily in this country, look no further than these beloved brands.
Scary Mommy’s readers have spoken! Congratulations to our 2026 top Domestic Wine Brands!
What Scary Mommy readers love about JUSTIN Vineyards & Winery:
- My go-to for all dinner parties! It tastes way pricier than the receipt says, and it’s the rare pick everyone at book club actually agrees on.
- Their Cab hits that golden middle ground—remarkably velvety, robust, and never aggressively dry when you finally sink into the couch after bedtime. 🍷
- Love the Sauvignon Blanc for sunny patio hangs with the girls, AND the Isosceles blend for celebrating surviving back-to-school week!
2. Decoy Wines
What Scary Mommy readers love about Decoy Wines:
- The Duckhorn pedigree at standard supermarket prices feels like a total grocery cart win! It transforms our family’s “Sunday sauce night” into a wine country escape without blowing our weekly budget.
- Their lower-alcohol Featherweight lineup is an answered prayer when I want a lighter evening treat! Bright, flavorful, and gentle enough to enjoy while cooking, so my 6 AM toddler wake-up isn’t a disaster!
3. Butter Wines
What Scary Mommy readers love about Butter Wines:
- The cans are the best when my partner isn't drinking! I don't have to open an entire bottle just for one glass and watch the rest spoil in the fridge.
- Bless them for the twist-off cap. By 8 PM, the last thing I have patience for is tearing apart the junk drawer to track down our missing corkscrew.
- Zero wine snobbery here—just super rich, smooth, and easy to sip. It’s my official pairing for sweatpants and trash TV once the house is finally quiet. 💯
4. FitVine
6. La Crema
Photos Courtesy of Bread & Butter, Butter Wines, Chateau Ste. Michelle, Decoy Wines, O'Neill Wine/FitVine, Justin, Kendall-Jackson, La Crema
Have questions? Read the official Readers' Choice rules.