11 Fall Brownies Recipes For The Perfect Autumn Baking Day

You knew pumpkin was going to be at the top of the list, right? These pumpkin cheesecake swirl brownies from A Pretty Life in the Suburbs are just incredible. Pumpkin is already pretty great in both sweet and savory dishes, but something about it mixed in here with the cheesecake taste and the chocolate will just send you over the edge. Super fudgy and moist, these brownies also just look perfect for a fall gathering.

There’s something about caramel that feels quintessentially fall — maybe all the Halloween candy? — so I’m obsessed with these caramel-filled brownies from Damn Delicious. With a layer of caramel in the middle oozing out with every bite, you’re sure to feel those warm, hearty, autumn food vibes.

Like caramel, toffee feels like a fall flavor, so I’m more than ready to whip up these toffee brownie cookies from A Spicy Perspective. It may be in a cookie shape, but that flavor and texture is all fudgy brownie, and the crunchy, sweet topping of toffee will make you feel like you fell into a gourd and live there with a bunch of fall fairies. (Yes, it’s that good.)

Ready to mash up all your favorite Halloween candy into a brownie for fall? I’ve got you covered. This Reese’s Fluffernutter Brownie recipe from Inside Bru Crew Life is beyond decadent. With Reese’s Pieces, peanut butter cups, and marshmallows, it’s like your trick-or-treat pail fell into a perfect pan of brownies.

You can’t have fall without caramel apple, so you might as well try it mixed into a brownie. From Foodie Crush, these delightful caramel apple brownies are like the perfect apple cake mashed into a brownie, and I’m just mad I’ve lived 36 years without this recipe.

For a classic fall brownie, try these pumpkin chocolate chip brownies from Averie Cooks. Nothing fancy here, just a good old fashioned brownie with everyone’s favorite fall gourd mixed right on in. The vibes are peak fall, and everyone’s going to want seconds.

More caramel, but this time we’re using Rolos, a very underrated candy. This salted Rolo brownies recipe from Brown Eyed Baker has a texture straight from heaven and makes for very thick, cakey brownies with the perfect salt to caramel ratio.

It just doesn’t get much more fall than this: pecan pie brownies. Cookie Named Desire’s recipe gives you a classic fudgy brownie bottom and then the perfectly sweet, crunchy pecan pie taste right on top. It’s all the things you love about both desserts, and the recipe is so simple. Don’t wait until Thanksgiving to make these.

All of the cinnamon sugar sweetness in snickerdoodles means they’re the perfect fall cookie, so why not try the snickerdoodle blondie bars from Baked By Rachel? My husband is a snickerdoodle expert and swears these blondie bars have the exact same soft, puffy texture of a snickerdoodle cookie — but they’re thicker. What more could you want?

Want a really easy fall brownie? Try this spice cake brownie recipe. The official name from Cookies and Cups is Spice Cake Knock You Naked Brownies and I have a feeling that’s an apt description. Using a spice cake box mix and a few simple pantry ingredients, you can have these delightful spice brownies all ready to impress.

OK, so maybe this is more of a Halloween brownie, but Halloween is in the fall, right? From Gimme Some Oven, these brownie spiders take no time at all to make and look adorable on a party platter or passed out as a sweet treat for friends and neighbors.