Parenting

Scary Mommy 2025 Readers’ Choice Awards Best Diapers

Because what you swaddle your newborn’s butt with matters.

by Team Scary Mommy
Scary Mommy 2025 Readers' Choice Awards

Congratulations, you’re having a baby! Now you have roughly 15,000 decisions to make. As the due date gets closer, one of the first things you’re likely to think of are what type of diaper will you use. Do you want to go organic or no? Do you want your newborn’s butt to be swaddled in something cute or do you not care? The list goes on and on. Here Scary Mommy rounded up the best of the best diapers, from the big brands like Pampers and Huggies to the smaller brands like Coterie and Naty. Vote away!

Have questions? Read the official Readers’ Choice rules.

What Scary Mommy readers love about Parasol Clear+Dry Natural Disposable Diapers:

  • Softest diaper on the market.
  • Clean ingredients (TCF) that leave no diaper rash, very good for the skin.
  • Stays drier throughout the night and keeps everything inside.
  • Great fit and an affordable price.
  • Easy autoship delivery.

What Scary Mommy readers love about Dyper Skin Happy Diapers:

  • Compostable through the Redyper service; better for the environment.
  • Soft, flexible bamboo diapers with no plastic on baby’s skin.
  • Great for sensitive skin; no diaper rash.
  • Super absorbent.
  • Sturdy but not bulky with a great fit.
  • Easy-to-manage subscription through the app.

What Scary Mommy readers love about Millie Moon Luxury Diapers:

  • Love this luxuriously soft nappy.
  • Incredibly reliable: brilliant absorbency, preventing leaks and blowouts. Keeps the bums dry.
  • Quality diapers that fit great and are affordable.
  • Totally hypoallergenic and helps with diaper rash.
  • The brand looks at what customers need.

Photos courtesy of Coterie Diapers, Dyper Skin Happy Diapers, Freestyle World, Inc., Procter & Gamble, Parasol Co., Pura Diapers